The Toronto Blue Jays face a crucial decision regarding Vladimir Guerrero Jr. as the 2025 MLB trade deadline approaches.
They could keep him, push for a playoff run, and attempt to re-sign him in free agency next offseason. Alternatively, they might trade him, shift toward a rebuild, and still pursue him in free agency.
Their choice will likely hinge on their competitiveness at the deadline. If they are in contention for a division title or playoff spot, a trade seems unlikely.
According to Bleacher Report’s Kerry Miller, the Blue Jays are expected to hold onto Guerrero for the entire 2025 season rather than moving him.
ChatGPT said:
Kerry Miller highlighted the uncertainty surrounding Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s future with the Blue Jays, noting that his status will depend on the team’s performance leading up to the trade deadline.
“The big question now is whether he’ll still be with the Blue Jays in August or if they’ll be far enough out of contention to consider trading him as a massive rental, similar to Manny Machado in 2018,” Miller wrote. “They’re not going to trade him before the season, though. That ship sailed when they invested in Andrés Giménez, Anthony Santander, Jeff Hoffman, and Max Scherzer. With those additions, they’re clearly planning to compete through the All-Star break before even considering an exit strategy.”
Given Toronto’s offseason moves to build a contender, it would be surprising to see them struggling in the AL East. If they stay in the race, keeping Guerrero makes the most sense. However, if they falter by the deadline, moving him for a significant prospect return could be a smart long-term play.