Speculation surrounding Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s future has intensified after the Blue Jays missed their self-imposed deadline to reach a contract extension with him, with rumors suggesting potential deals worth hundreds of millions. As a result, the Blue Jays are considering several internal candidates for the first base position, presenting an opportunity to step up, especially if Guerrero Jr. departs after the season.

Wagner had an impressive minor league season, walking 16.6% of the time while striking out only 10.4%. His brief MLB appearance also showed promise, displaying decent power alongside strong bat-to-ball skills. Set to have a strong 2025, Wagner is competing for the third base and designated hitter spots, but could also be a contender for first base. This flexibility would benefit the Blue Jays, allowing them to make roster adjustments without feeling pressured to make drastic moves.

Toronto should prioritize keeping Wagner’s bat in the lineup, considering his solid performance last season with a 125 wRC+, a .788 OPS, and an 18.6% strikeout rate. If he continues to develop, he could be a reliable first base option moving forward, provided he doesn’t secure a starting position elsewhere on the field.

Other candidates include minor leaguer Riley Tirotta and Davis Schneider. Tirotta, a 26-year-old non-roster invitee to spring training, posted solid numbers in Buffalo last season with 12 home runs, 40 RBI, and a .240 batting average. Meanwhile, Schneider had a tough 2024 but showed promise in 2023, which could give him a chance to redeem himself and prove his value.

The Blue Jays, despite not finalizing a contract with Guerrero Jr. before the season, will continue to explore both internal and external options to strengthen their roster. This season is critical for Toronto, as both Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette are set to become free agents, and a strong performance could lead to significant contract offers for both players.