John Tavares, Maple Leafs Agree on Extension Price, Says Insider
A new report suggests the Toronto Maple Leafs are closing in on a three-year contract extension with captain John Tavares. According to David Pagnotta of The Fourth Period, only minor details remain before the deal is finalized.
“There has been chatter of a three-year extension in place that requires some fine-tuning, but nobody will confirm. His AAV will drop, likely in the $7 million range,” Pagnotta reported.
A Fair Deal or an Overpay?
A contract of three more seasons at $7 million per year sparks debate. On one hand, Tavares remains a productive player, contributing offensively and providing leadership. On the other, at 34 years old, his role is expected to decline, making some wonder whether this deal is truly team-friendly.
Some fans believe the Leafs should be negotiating a lower cap hit, given that Tavares has no intention of leaving. Others question why Toronto is working to finalize the deal mid-season, rather than waiting until the summer.
What’s the Leafs’ Strategy?
Could Toronto be looking to set the market for pending UFAs? Are they trying to avoid last-minute bidding wars and potential complications?
With the March 7 trade deadline approaching, securing Tavares’ future now could provide clarity on the Leafs’ cap situation and allow GM Brad Treliving to focus on other roster needs—particularly at center and left wing.
As the details get ironed out, one thing is certain: locking up their captain is a major decision that will shape the team’s future for years to come.
What Is Fair Value for Tavares?
If the reported three-year, $7 million AAV deal for John Tavares is accurate, it’s bound to generate debate. While it represents a $4 million pay cut from his current contract, some argue that Toronto could have pushed for an even lower number given his age (34) and strong desire to stay.
The NHL’s projected cap increases over the next few years mean this deal wouldn’t cripple the Leafs’ flexibility, particularly when it comes to re-signing Mitch Marner. However, $7 million per season for a 34-year-old still raises questions.
Is This an Overpay?
Tavares remains a point-per-game player, so the number isn’t outrageous. But his case is unique. Unlike many UFAs who might test the market, Tavares has made it clear he doesn’t want to leave. That alone could have given Toronto leverage to negotiate a lower cap hit—potentially closer to $5 million per season.
Did the Salary Cap Jump Influence Negotiations?
The anticipated cap increase may have played a major role in the final number. With more spending power on the horizon, the Leafs might have been less aggressive in negotiating a deeper discount.
Ultimately, while $7 million for Tavares won’t break the bank, it does raise questions about whether the Leafs could have structured a more cap-friendly deal, especially as they juggle future contracts for key players.