As the preseason comes to a close and roster decisions approach, two Toronto Maple Leafs defensemen are in uncertain positions. Timothy Liljegren and Topi Niemelä, once viewed as key components of the team’s future, now face doubts about their roles. Their performances have raised more questions than clarity as the team gears up for the season opener.

While Niemelä may be viewed as a question for next season, Liljegren’s situation is more pressing. The Maple Leafs had seen both defensemen as part of their future plans, but Liljegren’s current circumstances are concerning.

Timothy Liljegren: Consistency Under Scrutiny

Following the signing of a two-year contract worth $3 million per season this summer, Liljegren was anticipated to secure his spot as a regular defenseman. However, his preseason performance has been underwhelming. Although he hasn’t been outright poor, he has shown a lack of spark, leading to growing concerns about his play.

In a recent matchup against the Detroit Red Wings, Liljegren logged considerable ice time, leading the team’s defensemen with 21:34 on the ice. However, instead of making a mark, he was outshone by less experienced players like Marshall Rifai and Philippe Myers and struggled to leave a strong impression. His performance lacked the assertiveness and consistency the Maple Leafs require from a player in his position, failing to assert his presence despite being one of the more seasoned defensemen on the ice. So, what’s next? Is his place in the starting lineup now in question?

The most significant indication of Liljegren’s shaky preseason is his exclusion from the Maple Leafs’ top three defensive pairings in recent practices. Initially seen as a contender for a depth role, Conor Timmins may have surpassed Liljegren in the lineup. If Liljegren plays in tonight’s final preseason game, his performance will be closely scrutinized. Should he fail to improve, he risks being a spectator from the press box when the regular season kicks off.

Topi Niemelä: From Top Prospect to the Edge of the Roster

Topi Niemelä entered last preseason as one of the Maple Leafs’ premier defensive prospects. Drafted 64th overall in the 2020 NHL Entry Draft, Niemelä was highly regarded for his offensive instincts and reliable defensive play. However, his lack of impact during the preseason has raised concerns. Has a decision already been made regarding his role on the team?

Thursday’s game against Detroit marked Niemelä’s first action of the preseason, but his performance did not instill confidence. He logged only slightly more ice time than rookie defenseman Cade Webber, indicating that the coaching staff may not fully believe he is ready for the NHL. There have been no reports of injuries or conditioning issues, leaving the reason for his absence from earlier preseason games unclear.

This raises the question: Did Niemelä arrive at camp unprepared, or has the team soured on his potential?

Niemelä’s future with the Maple Leafs may still hold promise, but this preseason has done little to bolster his case for a roster spot. The team could opt to send him back to the American Hockey League (AHL) for further development, and his progress will be closely watched as the season unfolds. At this stage in his career, playing with the Toronto Marlies is acceptable, but more was expected — and sooner.

Final Decisions for Liljegren and Niemelä Approaching

As the preseason wraps up, the Maple Leafs face some difficult choices. Liljegren and Niemelä were once regarded as key pieces of the team’s defensive future, but their recent performances have muddied those expectations. While Liljegren’s NHL experience gives him an advantage, his inconsistency opens the door for other defensemen to take their place. On the other hand, Niemelä may require more time to develop, but his lack of impact this preseason is concerning.

The Maple Leafs need to decide whether to allow Liljegren and Niemelä more time to demonstrate their potential or explore other alternatives. The final preseason game could be pivotal in shaping their futures, as both players might begin the season outside the main lineup.