In the day-to-day grind of a 162-game baseball season, it’s sometimes necessary to step back and consider the bigger picture.
Nearly a decade ago, the Toronto Blue Jays made a pivotal move by bringing in Mark Shapiro as team president while losing their successful general manager, Alex Anthopoulos. The outcome, however, hasn’t been a slam dunk but rather a series of near misses.
Reflecting on Shapiro’s arrival in the summer of 2015, amidst the thrilling late-season surge that saw the Blue Jays transform from underachievers to American League East champions, the excitement was palpable. This surge, which ended a 22-year playoff drought, was propelled in large part by Anthopoulos’s bold trades for David Price, Troy Tulowitzki, and Ben Revere. Anthopoulos was widely hailed as baseball’s Executive of the Year by his peers.
However, Shapiro’s mandate was clear from the start: modernize the business operations and take charge of baseball decisions. Despite Anthopoulos’s success and popularity, Shapiro’s vision did not align with keeping him onboard. After the Jays fell to Kansas City in the AL Championship Series, Anthopoulos resigned, declining an offer to remain with full autonomy over baseball operations.
Anthopoulos went on to achieve success with the Atlanta Braves, winning the NL East consistently and securing a World Series victory in 2021. Meanwhile, the Blue Jays, after their thrilling 2015 run, have struggled in the playoffs and failed to capitalize on their potential, despite sporadic bursts of promise.
Under Shapiro and general manager Ross Atkins, the Blue Jays have leaned heavily on analytics and cautious player acquisitions, diverging from Anthopoulos’s more aggressive approach. While investments like the Rogers Centre renovation and player development complex in Dunedin have modernized facilities, on-field success remains elusive. The team’s farm system ranks poorly, and recent playoff bids have faltered, leaving fans skeptical amidst rising ticket prices.
As the AL East grows more competitive, with powerhouses like the Yankees and emerging talent in Baltimore, the Jays’ conservative approach may not suffice. There’s a growing sentiment that a rebuild may be necessary, especially if cornerstone players like Bo Bichette and Vladimir Guerrero Jr. don’t solidify their roles as long-term leaders.
Ultimately, Shapiro’s tenure has brought financial stability and infrastructure improvements, but the on-field results have yet to match the initial excitement of the Anthopoulos era. The quest for sustained success remains uncertain, and the contrast between Shapiro’s corporate strategy and Anthopoulos’s bold vision continues to define the Blue Jays’ recent history.
GET MORE NEWS HERE