The Toronto Maple Leafs have no valid excuse to delay signing Mitch Marner and Matthew Knies to long-term deals. Both players have proven their worth. Marner, in particular, has stepped up as the team’s leader in Auston Matthews’ absence. His overtime goal against the Edmonton Oilers on Saturday night showcased his ability to deliver when it counts.
Knies has been equally impressive. He has emerged as the power forward the Leafs have long been missing, reminiscent of players like Dave Andreychuk or Gary Roberts. Expected to have a breakout season, Knies has exceeded expectations so far.
One key reason why the Leafs must act now is the anticipated increase in the NHL’s salary cap. According to insider Elliotte Friedman, the cap, currently at $88 million, could rise to between $95 and $97 million next season, well above the 5% growth limit outlined in the CBA. This potential $7 to $9 million increase provides the Leafs with ample room to accommodate raises for Marner and Knies. Additionally, if John Tavares re-signs at a lower rate, Toronto could also pursue a top-tier goaltender or other free agents.
This cap increase couldn’t come at a better time for the Leafs, but they must act quickly to avoid missing their window.
The Leafs Should Commit to Marner and Knies
Negotiations over the summer reportedly hit a snag because the team was reluctant to meet Marner’s asking price, which is rumored to be close to Auston Matthews’ salary—around $13 million. With the cap increase, the Leafs should stop hesitating and pay Marner what he’s worth. He has carried the team in Matthews’ absence, and his leadership and performance make him indispensable. In fact, had Matthews not been named captain, Marner’s recent contributions might have earned him the role.
The Leafs should also secure Knies with a deal in the $5–$6 million range annually. Given the expected cap growth in the coming years, the contracts for Matthews, Marner, and Knies could soon look like bargains.
Another compelling reason to act now is Connor McDavid’s potential contract extension, which could make him the NHL’s first $15 million player. If McDavid signs before Marner, it could drive Marner’s asking price even higher, complicating negotiations further.
Conclusion: Time to Invest in the Future
The Leafs need to stop delaying and secure both Marner and Knies. By doing so, they can focus on building a roster capable of competing for the Stanley Cup. It’s time for Toronto to put their money where their ambitions are and take the next step toward building a championship team.