The New York Islanders are facing a tough situation with a series of injuries to key players, the latest being Adam Pelech, who will be out for at least a month. As a result, the team is in urgent need of defensive help, particularly on the left side. While the trade market is limited, one potential solution could be Matt Benning, recently acquired by the Toronto Maple Leafs from the San Jose Sharks.

With little cap space available, the Islanders likely can’t afford to target high-profile players, but Benning could provide a cost-effective option to strengthen their blue line. Benning, a 30-year-old defenseman with 464 NHL games of experience, brings solid defensive reliability, something the Islanders could use as they try to remain competitive. Last season, he posted 24 points, 125 blocked shots, and 122 hits over 77 games—impressive stats for a depth player—and his affordable $1.25 million cap hit makes him an attractive option for a team like the Islanders.

Although Benning is currently with the Leafs, his chances of playing regularly in Toronto are slim due to their increasingly healthy roster, which has pushed him further down the depth chart. This situation could give him a better opportunity for consistent minutes in New York, where he could step in for Pelech. A trade to the Islanders wouldn’t require a large return, and the Leafs would likely be willing to move him to a team where he can get more ice time and contribute. While some might question if this move is the best for Benning’s career, at least it would offer him a chance to play meaningful minutes.