Blue Jays’ GM Ross Atkins is under intense scrutiny for sticking with a strategy that hasn’t worked, as key players like Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Bo Bichette, Chris Bassitt, and Chad Green are set to hit free agency after the 2025 season. Attempts to extend Guerrero have failed, and the team has struggled since 2019, with three Wild Card appearances but no wins. In 2024, the Blue Jays finished last in the AL East with a sub-.500 record.
Despite this, Atkins has doubled down, believing the Blue Jays can secure postseason victories next year. To turn things around, Toronto needs a major overhaul, with their 22nd-ranked team ERA and 17th-ranked team OPS in 2024 highlighting the need for improvement. The worst-case scenario is another mediocre season, missing the chance to trade key players while they still have value.
Amidst the criticism, Atkins could redeem himself with some key free agent signings — or risk making poor choices. Here are six signings to consider and two to avoid:
Signings to Make
6. Alex Bregman
A cornerstone of the Astros dynasty, Bregman is a solid defender and consistent hitter. Despite a down year due to injuries in 2024, his postseason experience and overall track record make him a valuable addition for the Blue Jays.
5. Jurickson Profar
Profar had a career year in 2024, slashing .280/.380/.459 with 24 home runs. His bat could add much-needed depth behind Guerrero, especially with Bichette’s injury issues.
4. Teoscar Hernández:
A former Blue Jay, Hernández is a reliable hitter who notched 32 home runs in 2024. Bringing him back could fill a critical void in the lineup.
3. Corbin Burnes
As the top pitcher on the market, Burnes could be the ace Toronto desperately needs. With a 2.92 ERA in 2024, his addition could turn the Blue Jays’ rotation into one capable of a World Series run.
2. Anthony Santander
Santander’s 44 home runs in 2024 show he’s a legitimate power hitter. He would help shore up Toronto’s power deficiency and provide financial flexibility for other moves.
1. Juan Soto
Soto’s ability to get on base and hit for power makes him the top free agent. Pairing him with Guerrero at the top of the lineup would be a game-changer for Toronto’s postseason hopes.
Signings to Avoid
2. Justin Verlander
Though Verlander has had a Hall of Fame career, his 2024 performance was poor, and at 42, he’s too risky given Toronto’s urgent need for consistency.
1. Shane Bieber
Bieber’s injury history and uncertain return make him a risky bet. With Toronto’s limited time to win, the Blue Jays would be better off investing in a more reliable arm.